Rating the Proposal

Step 5: Using the Star Ratings

A standard rating scale is to be used by all reviewers.
☆ - Indicates the proposal should be declined.
☆☆ - Indicates the proposal is of below average quality and should probably be declined.
☆☆☆ - Indicates the proposal could be included or could be held as a potential replacement in case of cancellations.
☆☆☆☆ - Indicates the proposal is very good and should be included if space permits.
☆☆☆☆☆ - Indicates that the proposal is of exceptional quality and should definitely be included in the program.

Click on the appropriate star to indicate your summary evaluation of the proposal. The system automatically averages the ratings of all reviewers. Once your review is complete and saved, your rating will be added to the calculation.

Rate based on quality and comment on fit for the unit. A low rating based on fit will impact consideration of the proposal for an open session. Issues of fit should be handled in the comments.

Star Ratings

To see the next step, select Leaving Comments below.